·

Italian Sloppy Joes

open faced Italian Sloppy Joe sitting on black surface with basil leaves

We may earn from qualifying purchases from links in this post.

If you love Sloppy Joes and Italian flavors, these Italian Sloppy Joes are exactly what you’ve been waiting for! I worked on this recipe several times until I landed on exactly the flavor I was after. It took a few rounds of tasting and adjusting, but this is the version I’m excited to share.

Italian Sloppy Joe sandwich sitting on black surface with basil leaves

I like to start by building a base full of Italian flavor. You can certainly make this with store-bought marinara sauce, but this from-scratch version is the one I’m hooked on. It’s great for pasta, pizza, and as a dipping sauce.

Start by sautéing garlic, oregano, basil, and red pepper flakes in olive oil until they become fragrant, then stir in crushed tomatoes and seasonings to make a thick, rich sauce. I recommend San Marzano crushed tomatoes.

Italian Sloppy Joe sandwich cut in half sitting on black surface with basil leaves

Use whatever sausage you prefer: sweet, mild, or hot. I prefer using a mix of mild and sweet. By making this with Italian sausage alongside the flavors in that marinara, you’re creating the twist that makes the sandwich what it is.

And what’s a Sloppy Joe without peppers and onions? Like a traditional Sloppy Joe, the green bell pepper and onion cook right into this mixture, adding sweetness and body. Tomato paste helps thicken everything, and Parmesan adds more of that Italian flavor.

Each sandwich comes together on a toasted bun and topped with melted mozzarella. This hearty sandwich is great any day of the week, and it’s especially perfect for game day.

Italian Sloppy Joe sandwich sitting on black plate

Why You’ll Love These Italian Sloppy Joes

Big flavor from scratch. A simple marinara built on garlic, herbs, and San Marzano tomatoes gives the sandwich its Italian character.

Italian sausage adds a twist. Sweet, mild, or hot (or a mix), the Italian sausage brings a flavor that ground beef can’t replicate.

Fresh mozzarella under the broiler. Those two minutes of broiling time turn the mozzarella bubbly and golden-brown. Skip the pre-shredded bag version.

Built for a crowd. One pot feeds eight on toasted brioche buns, or stretches further if you go the slider route.

Make-ahead friendly. The sausage mixture keeps well in the refrigerator and freezes. Just toast fresh buns and add fresh cheese on the day you serve it.

Italian Sloppy Joes sitting on black surface

About the From-Scratch Marinara

The marinara is made separately in a second skillet while the sausage is browning. The two happen simultaneously so the total cook time is not doubled. It’s a quick sauce: garlic and dried herbs bloom in olive oil for about a minute until the kitchen smells like an Italian restaurant, then crushed tomatoes go in and the whole thing simmers for 20 minutes until thickened.

San Marzano crushed tomatoes are the recommendation. Imported from Italy, they are sweeter and less acidic than standard canned crushed tomatoes and produce a noticeably better marinara. The finished sauce goes straight into the sausage mixture rather than onto the plate, so every bite of filling has that herb and garlic flavor built right in.

This marinara is also worth making on its own for pasta, pizza, or as a dipping sauce alongside the finished sandwiches. It’s a good one to have in the regular rotation.

Italian Sloppy Joes sitting on black surface with hand raising top bun

What You’ll Need

The Marinara

Olive oil, garlic, and dried herbs: The key step is cooking the garlic, oregano, basil, and red pepper flakes in the oil before the tomatoes go in, about one minute over medium-low until fragrant. This blooms the herbs and infuses the oil so the flavor is built into the sauce from the start.

Crushed tomatoes (San Marzano): The full can goes in with all its juice.

Sugar, salt, and pepper: A small amount of sugar balances the acidity of the tomatoes. Season the sauce as it simmers and adjust to taste before adding it to the sausage mixture.

The Sausage Mixture

Italian sausage: I recommend a mix of sweet and mild. Hot sausage can replace either pound for more heat. Stick with Italian sausage rather than ground beef. The spice blend built into the sausage gives this sandwich its flavor boost.

Green bell pepper and white onion: Diced and added after the sausage browns.

Tomato paste: Thickens the mixture and adds a concentrated tomato richness.

Freshly grated Parmesan: Stirred in with the marinara and tomato paste. Use freshly grated from a block. Pre-grated has a coating that prevents it from melting smoothly into the mixture.

For Serving

Brioche buns: Toasted first. A soggy bun under this much sauce and cheese is a structural problem that a light toast prevents completely. Buttered and griddled is the best version.

Fresh mozzarella: Two ounces per sandwich, sliced. Fresh mozzarella melts into pillowy, bubbly pools under the broiler. Pre-shredded packaged mozzarella won’t give you the same result.

Italian Sloppy Joes sitting on black surface

How to Make Italian Sloppy Joes

Cook the marinara and sausage mixture simultaneously in their own skillets. Start the marinara first, then begin browning the sausage while it simmers. They finish at about the same time.

Make the marinara. Bloom the garlic and herbs in olive oil for one minute, then add the tomatoes and seasonings. Simmer on medium-low for 20 minutes until thickened, stirring occasionally.

Brown the sausage and add the vegetables. Both sausages go in together. Once browned, add the diced bell pepper and onion and cook about 5 minutes until starting to soften. Drain the grease off the heat before adding anything else.

Combine and simmer. Add the finished marinara, tomato paste, and Parmesan. Stir well to combine, bring to a gentle simmer, then cover and cook on medium-low for 25 minutes, stirring often. Tip the lid over the sink when you remove it to dump the condensation; water dripping back in thins the sauce.

Italian Sloppy Joe mix with shredded white cheese

Toast the buns, assemble, and broil. Preheat the oven to 350°F. Toast the buns in butter on a griddle or cut side up in the oven for 3 to 4 minutes. Place the toasted bottom buns on a greased sheet pan, spoon on the filling, top each with 2 oz of sliced mozzarella. Bake 8 minutes, then broil 2 minutes until the cheese is bubbly and golden. Watch it closely – the line between golden and burnt is about 30 seconds.

The sausage mixture can be made a day ahead and refrigerated. Reheat gently on the stove, then toast fresh buns and add fresh cheese on the day you serve. The sandwich is better with fresh bread and cheese every time.

open faced sandwiches with Italian Sloppy Joe mix and fresh sliced mozzarella on brown pan

How to Serve

Game day spread: Set out the sheet pan of assembled sandwiches right from the oven with extra marinara for dipping.

Weeknight dinner: One pot of filling makes 8 sandwiches. Plenty for a family dinner with leftovers for the next day.

As sliders: Use smaller brioche slider buns and stretch the filling further. Great for parties where people want to try multiple things.

With extra marinara on the side: The sauce doubles as a dipping sauce. Set out a small bowl alongside the sandwiches for those who want even more of it.

open faced Italian Sloppy Joe sitting on black surface with basil leaves

Frequently Asked Questions

Italian Sloppy Joe sandwich sitting on black plate

Italian Sloppy Joe’s

Kimberly Smith
A from-scratch twist on the classic Sloppy Joe. Italian sausage browned with bell pepper and onion, combined with a homemade San Marzano marinara and Parmesan, simmered until thick and rich, then loaded onto toasted buttered brioche buns with fresh mozzarella melted under the broiler. Hearty, flavorful, and built for game day or any weeknight dinner.
Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 55 minutes
Total Time 1 hour 15 minutes
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Servings 8
Calories 818 kcal

Equipment

  • deep skillet or Dutch oven
  • second skillet (for marinara)
  • sheet pan
  • griddle or oven (for buns)

Ingredients
  

Marinara

  • 2 Tbsp olive oil
  • 3 cloves garlic (minced)
  • 1 tsp dried oregano
  • 1 tsp dried basil
  • ½ tsp crushed red pepper flakes
  • 28 oz crushed tomatoes (San Marzano)
  • 1 ½ tsp sugar
  • ½ tsp kosher salt
  • ½ tsp freshly cracked black pepper

Sausage Mixture

  • 1 lb sweet Italian sausage
  • 1 lb mild Italian sausage
  • 1 large green bell pepper (diced)
  • 1 medium white onion (diced)
  • 6 oz tomato paste
  • ¼ cup Parmesan cheese (freshly grated)

For Serving

  • 8 brioche buns
  • 16 oz fresh mozzarella (sliced, 2 oz per sandwich)
  • butter (for toasting the buns)

Instructions
 

Marinara (Start First)

  • In a skillet, heat the olive oil over medium-low heat. Add the garlic, oregano, basil, and red pepper flakes. Cook, stirring, for about 1 minute until fragrant.
  • Stir in the crushed tomatoes, sugar, salt, and pepper. Bring to a simmer over medium heat, then reduce to medium-low and simmer for 20 minutes, stirring occasionally, until thickened. Set aside.

Sausage Mixture (Start While Marinara Simmers)

  • In a deep skillet or Dutch oven, brown both sausages together over medium-high heat, breaking up with a wooden spoon, until fully cooked through.
  • Add the diced bell pepper and onion. Cook for about 5 minutes, stirring, until beginning to soften. Turn off the heat and carefully drain the grease.
  • Add the finished marinara, tomato paste, and Parmesan. Stir until well combined. Bring to a simmer over medium heat, then reduce to medium-low, cover, and simmer for 25 minutes, stirring often. When lifting the lid, tip it over the sink to drain the condensation so it doesn't drip back into the sauce.

Toast, Assemble & Broil

  • Preheat the oven to 350°F (175°C). Toast the buns: melt butter on a griddle and cook each bun cut side down until golden, or place cut side up on a sheet pan and toast in the oven for 3 to 4 minutes.
  • Lightly grease a sheet pan. Place the toasted bun bottoms on the pan and spoon the sausage mixture evenly onto each one. Top each with 2 oz of sliced fresh mozzarella. Bake for 8 minutes, then switch the oven to broil and broil for approximately 2 minutes until the cheese is bubbly and golden brown. Watch closely so the bun edges don’t burn. Finish with the top buns and serve immediately.

Notes

Make ahead:

  • The sausage mixture can be made 1 to 2 days ahead. Cool completely and refrigerate in an airtight container.
  • Reheat gently on the stove over medium-low, stirring often, until hot.
  • Always toast fresh buns and use fresh mozzarella on the day you serve.
 

How to store:

  • Store the sausage mixture in an airtight container in the refrigerator for 3 to 4 days.
  • Do not store assembled sandwiches. Toast fresh buns and add fresh mozzarella each time.
  • Reheat on the stove over medium-low stirring often, or microwave in a covered dish stirring halfway through.
 

Freezing:

  • Cool the sausage mixture completely. Freeze in airtight containers or flat freezer bags for up to 3 months. Leave a little room at the top for expansion.
  • Freezing in single-serving portions makes weeknight sandwiches easy. Simply thaw only what you need.
  • Do not freeze the mozzarella. It turns watery and loses its stretch when thawed. Always use fresh.
  • Thaw overnight in the refrigerator. Reheat on the stove, then assemble with fresh buns and cheese.
 
Nutritional information provided is an estimate only, calculated using online calculators and do not include suggested or optional ingredients. Variations can occur due to ingredient freshness, brands, and measuring techniques.
Keyword Entertaining Recipes, Freezer Friendly, Weeknight Dinners

Did You Make This Recipe?

Let us know in the comments below and share a photo on Facebook or Instagram. Mention or tag @countrygardensandtable!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating